NASA Reforms Scientific Mission Selection Process, Reducing Proposal Review Time to 19.5 Months

·by Henderson·Engineering
NASA Reforms Scientific Mission Selection Process, Reducing Proposal Review Time to 19.5 Months
Key Points
  • NASA is reforming its scientific mission selection process to reduce proposal costs and simplify the process.
  • The new system will prioritize scientific objectives before requiring detailed information, reducing the burden.
  • The reformed selection timeline will be shortened to approximately 19.5 months, enhancing mission concept maturity.
  • NASA will maintain strict cost and schedule controls to ensure the scientific value of missions.

NASA is undertaking a comprehensive reform of its scientific mission selection process, aiming to lower proposal costs, streamline the competitive process, and accelerate the development of more spacecraft. This new approach will prioritize scientific value in early assessments, allowing research teams to defer detailed engineering and financial planning. This reform, known as Competitive Model 2.0 (CM 2.0), was announced by Nicky Fox, Deputy Director of NASA's Science Mission Directorate. These changes, guided by NASA Administrator Jared Isaacman, are intended to make mission competition more accessible to scientists, universities, NASA centers, and commercial organizations.

Fox acknowledged that the current process places a significant burden on research teams, which must invest substantial time and resources in preparing proposals that may never receive funding. The new system aims to address this issue by evaluating scientific objectives before requiring detailed technical and financial information.

Main Changes in the New System

Under the current system, NASA invites scientists and research institutions to compete for mission funding through opportunity announcements. Applicants must provide detailed engineering and cost information before the agency selects finalists for further study. This two-phase process typically takes nearly three years. The reformed selection timeline will vary based on mission category. Planetary exploration missions, New Frontiers spacecraft, and Astro-Probes focused on medium-sized astronomical missions will retain the two-phase selection process, but the materials required for preliminary proposals will be reduced by nearly half.

NASA expects this will shorten the selection time from 35 months to approximately 19.5 months. The agency also anticipates that the revised process will yield more mature mission concepts at the time of selection.

Medium Explorer (MIDEX) and Earth Exploration Missions will also retain a two-phase process while expanding the competitive scope to include universities and commercial entities. NASA plans to evaluate developers based on their experience with projects of similar scale, cost, and complexity. Principal investigator-led teams can also request early support from the Goddard Space Flight Center or Jet Propulsion Laboratory (JPL). Flagship missions, including the James Webb Space Telescope (JWST), will continue to follow the existing selection procedures. NASA recently revised these procedures, drawing lessons from best practices in large mission development.

Selection Process for Smaller Projects

For its smaller, low-cost projects, NASA plans to implement more substantive changes. Small Explorer (SMEX) and Earth Venture Missions, as well as opportunities for payloads and rideshare missions, will shift to a single-phase selection process. The elimination of the second round of competitive proposals is expected to reduce the timeline for final selection from approximately 32 months to 19 months. NASA believes these projects can benefit from the increasingly mature commercial space industry, which offers more opportunities to leverage existing spacecraft capabilities and services. "Our smallest missions will leverage the momentum of the increasingly mature commercial space economy to further accelerate the process," Fox wrote.

The agency also hopes that Goddard and JPL will play a stronger role in developing scientific missions, as close involvement can improve coordination between centers, reduce internal competition, and retain NASA's technical expertise.

However, accelerating selection does not mean a reduction in oversight. NASA plans to maintain strict cost and schedule controls within its mission programs. Fox warned that violations of established thresholds could have serious consequences, including mission cancellation. The broader goal is to reduce the effort required to compete for NASA funding while helping more scientifically valuable ideas become actual missions. As Fox stated, the aim is "more missions, more frequently, and achieving more amazing science at lower costs."

How NASA is Accelerating the Selection of Scientific Missions

NASA's reforms aim to enhance the efficiency of scientific mission selection, particularly in the current competitive landscape of space exploration. By simplifying the proposal process and shortening review times, NASA hopes to attract more scientists and institutions to participate and foster innovation. These changes will not only reduce the burden on research teams but also accelerate the implementation of missions, thereby advancing the pace of scientific discovery. Despite the expedited selection process, NASA emphasizes the necessity of maintaining strict oversight to ensure mission success and scientific value.

H
About the author
Henderson