Why Data Centers Cannot Simply Be Relocated to the Arctic or Underwater?

·by Henderson·Engineering
Why Data Centers Cannot Simply Be Relocated to the Arctic or Underwater?
Key Points
  • Data centers require significant power to cool servers, with overheating being a major challenge.
  • The Arctic region can utilize free cooling technology, but construction faces challenges related to power and infrastructure.
  • The technical feasibility of underwater data centers has been tested, but commercial viability remains unproven.
  • Site selection for data centers must consider multiple factors, including power, connectivity, and economic costs.

Data centers have a rather inconvenient habit of overheating. Thousands of processors generate significant amounts of heat while performing calculations, training artificial intelligence models, and storing global digital information. Keeping this hardware from overheating requires substantial power consumption, making cooling one of the industry's biggest engineering challenges. So why not place these facilities in naturally cold locations? The Arctic offers plenty of cold air, while the ocean provides relatively cool water. An even better option would be to place the servers underwater, allowing the ocean to handle the cooling.

This seems like an obvious solution, and engineers have explored both ideas. However, building a data center involves much more than simply keeping its servers cool.

Cooling Technology Advantages in the Arctic

The Arctic region has advantages when it comes to cooling. Data centers in cold climates can employ a technique known as free cooling. This method does not rely entirely on energy-intensive cooling machines and refrigeration systems but can utilize external cold air or water to remove heat from the equipment. This can significantly reduce the power needed for cooling, which is one reason many companies choose to establish data centers in places like Sweden, Finland, Iceland, and Norway. For example, Google’s facility in Hamina, Finland, uses seawater from the Gulf of Finland as part of its cooling system. However, there are differences between constructing in cold countries and building in the Arctic wilderness.

The further north the facility is located, the more difficult it becomes to obtain reliable power, high-capacity fiber optic networks, skilled workers, and transportation infrastructure. Data centers may require less power to cool servers, but they still need substantial power to operate them. This has become an increasingly important limiting factor. The International Energy Agency has highlighted the growing power demands of data centers, while delays in grid connections and limited power infrastructure are becoming major obstacles to expansion.

Challenges of Underwater Data Centers

In other words, finding a cold piece of land is much easier than locating a large computing facility that can reliably supply power. There is also the issue of access. Construction materials, replacement servers, and maintenance personnel must traverse areas with harsh climates, remote distances, and limited transportation links, making even routine operations complex. Permafrost and the changing Arctic environment present further engineering challenges for construction and infrastructure. So, what about placing data centers underwater? The ocean offers another enticing option. Submerging a sealed facility allows heat to dissipate into the surrounding water and may reduce the need for traditional cooling equipment.

Microsoft has actually tested this idea through Project Natick. In 2018, the company deployed a sealed data center module off the coast of the Orkney Islands in Scotland. This underwater facility is about the size of a shipping container, housing 864 servers, and operated for over two years. The results were quite remarkable. According to Microsoft research, the server failure rate in the underwater facility was only one-eighth that of the corresponding land-based control group. The company believes that the controlled environment filled with dry nitrogen, rather than regular air, helps explain this difference.

The project demonstrated that underwater data centers are technically feasible, but it did not prove that they are commercially viable at scale.

Imagine a hard drive failure in a traditional data center. Technicians can walk over to replace it and get the equipment running again. Now imagine the same failure occurring several meters underwater. The entire sealed module may need to be recovered, transported to the surface, opened, repaired, and then redeployed. This is a rather costly replacement method. Underwater facilities also require reliable power and high-capacity connectivity to land networks. Laying and maintaining underwater cables adds to costs and complexity, while seawater, pressure, corrosion, and the marine environment present additional engineering challenges.

Microsoft's experiment succeeded in key technical aspects, but the company ultimately chose to abandon the project. According to Data Center Dynamics, Microsoft confirmed in June 2024 that it would no longer pursue plans for underwater data centers. The company stated that it would apply the lessons learned from the project to other areas of its business.

Multiple Considerations in Data Center Site Selection

Cooling is not the only consideration in the business. Another factor is the location of data center customers. Cloud services, online gaming, financial transactions, and many artificial intelligence applications rely on fast communication between users and servers. Establishing facilities outside population centers and network hubs increases latency, which is the time it takes for data to be transmitted between devices and servers. This may be inconsequential for some large-scale computing tasks, but it is critical for applications that require near-instantaneous responses. Furthermore, economic factors must also be considered. Data center operators must account for costs related to land, construction, power, cooling, networking, staffing, maintenance, and regulations, which can persist for decades.

Cheap cooling systems do not automatically make the construction and operation of the entire facility cheaper. The American Society of Heating, Refrigerating and Air-Conditioning Engineers (ASHRAE) lists power availability, grid capacity, cooling needs, and permitting as important factors in data center site selection. The Arctic and ocean remain interesting options for specialized facilities, particularly when renewable energy, suitable network connectivity, and local infrastructure are available. However, currently, the best data center locations are not necessarily the coldest places on Earth, but rather where factors such as power, connectivity, cooling, maintenance, and economics work together.

Unfortunately, for those hoping to place cloud services in icy clouds, the geographical situation is much more complex.

Complexities and Challenges in Data Center Construction

Building data centers involves not only challenges related to cooling technology but also considerations of power supply, infrastructure, and economic factors. While placing data centers in the Arctic or underwater can take advantage of natural cooling, the power demands and maintenance difficulties make these options complex. Although underwater facilities are technically feasible, their high maintenance costs and connectivity issues pose challenges to commercialization. Ultimately, the best site for data centers requires a balance among cooling, power, and economic factors.

H
About the author
Henderson